Sell your records

Where to sell records in New Jersey

10 shops in New Jersey buy records or whole collections.

Call before you go. A shop that buys records still decides what it wants from your collection on the day. New to selling? Read how selling to a shop works and how records are graded.

Bayonne 1 shop

  • 14a Records

    Open 1pm-7pm today

    Bayonne record store opened in January 2025 by Robert Henry, selling new and vintage records, tapes, CDs and rare imports, and buying record collections of all sizes.

    3 sources

All 1 record store in Bayonne

Bayville 1 shop

  • The Vinyl Dinosaur

    Open 12pm-6pm today

    Full-service Ocean County music shop in Bayville selling vinyl, CDs, cassettes, DVDs, books, turntables and other audio gear.

    5 sources

All 1 record store in Bayville

Haddonfield 1 shop

  • Haddonfield Record Exchange

    Open 12pm-6pm today

    South Jersey shop near Camden buying, selling and trading vinyl and CDs, with additional appointment-based hours beyond its posted walk-in days and a member loyalty program.

    2 sources

All 1 record store in Haddonfield

Milltown 1 shop

  • Revilla Grooves and Gear

    Open 10am-8pm today

    Milltown record and audio-gear shop with 20,000+ new and used LPs, 45s, CDs and box sets; hosts live performances and Record Store Day events in its in-store Performance Lounge.

    1 source

All 1 record store in Milltown

Montclair 1 shop

  • Almost Ready Records (Montclair)

    Open Hours not listed

    Montclair record shop, distinct from the Brooklyn shop of the same name; sells on Discogs and eBay in addition to its storefront.

    4 sources

All 2 record stores in Montclair

New Brunswick 1 shop

  • Spina Records

    Open 12pm-8pm today

    Widely praised as one of central New Jersey's best record stores, with a large rotating selection and strong jazz section, near Rutgers.

    4 sources

All 1 record store in New Brunswick

Paramus 1 shop

  • The Sharp Notes

    Open 10am-9:30pm today

    New and used records, CDs and audio gear on the second floor of the Garden State Plaza mall.

    2 sources

All 1 record store in Paramus

Pompton Lakes 1 shop

  • Station 1 Books & Vinyl

    Open 12pm-7pm today

    Books, vinyl and vintage shop at the Pompton Lakes train station.

    4 sources

All 2 record stores in Pompton Lakes

Princeton 1 shop

  • Princeton Record Exchange

    Open 10am-8pm today

    One of the largest independent used-record stores in the United States, trading in Princeton since 1980 with roughly 140,000 titles across vinyl, CDs and DVDs.

    8 sources

All 1 record store in Princeton

Red Bank 1 shop

  • Jack's Music Shoppe

    Open 10am-7pm today

    Longtime Red Bank record and music store on Broad Street.

    4 sources

All 1 record store in Red Bank