Sell your records

How records are graded

Almost every record shop describes condition with the same short scale. Knowing it shows you how a shop will see your records, and why two copies of the same album can get very different offers.

The scale

The scale is the Goldmine grading standard, named for the collectors' magazine and price guide that set it out. Discogs, the online marketplace, uses it for every listing, and shops use the same names or something close to them. It runs from Mint at the top down to Poor.

  1. Mint

    M

    The record

    Perfect and unplayed, often still sealed. No mark of any kind.

    The sleeve

    Perfect, with no wear anywhere.

    Shops use this grade sparingly, and many never do, because hardly any record is truly perfect.

  2. Near Mint

    NM, or M-

    The record

    Looks as if it has barely been played, and plays without noise from the disc itself.

    The sleeve

    No creases, seam splits, cut corners or ring wear. At most a trace of handling.

    For many shops this is the best grade they will give.

  3. Very Good Plus

    VG+

    The record

    Looked after by a careful owner. It may have light scuffs, fine marks or a slight warp, but it plays well and the flaws do not get in the way of the music.

    The sleeve

    Slight wear, such as softened corners, a little ring wear or a small seam split.

    Near Mint, but for a couple of minor flaws.

  4. Very Good

    VG

    The record

    Played a fair amount. You will hear surface noise, most of all in quiet passages and at the start and end of tracks, but the music still comes through. Light scratches you can feel with a fingernail.

    The sleeve

    More wear than VG+: ring wear, seam splits, writing, tape or stickers, though usually not all at once.

  5. Good, Good Plus

    G, G+

    The record

    Plays through without skipping, but with heavy surface noise and visible wear in the grooves.

    The sleeve

    Seam splits, tape, writing and ring wear are all likely.

  6. Fair, Poor

    F, P

    The record

    Cracked, badly warped, or it skips and repeats. Not reliably playable.

    The sleeve

    Water damaged, split along several seams, or barely holding the record in.

    Many shops will pass on records in this condition.

The record and the sleeve are graded apart

A shop usually writes two grades for a record, the disc first and the sleeve second, as in NM / VG+. Both count. A clean disc in a split sleeve is harder to resell than the same disc in a clean one.

Why the grade changes the offer

A shop that buys a record is also deciding how to sell it. The grade it gives sets the price the record will carry on the shelf, and the offer is worked back from that. A record that grades one step lower sells for less, so the offer is lower too. That is why condition is the first thing a shop checks.

The shop's grade can differ from yours, and the shop's grade is the one that counts. It has to stand behind that grade to the next buyer.

Check your own records before you go

  • Tilt each disc under a bright light and look at both sides for scuffs and scratches.
  • Sight along the edge of the disc to spot a warp.
  • Look at the sleeve: seams, corners, ring wear, writing, tape and stickers.
  • Check the label for tears, marks and ring wear.

A record can look clean and still be noisy, so a shop may play a few from a collection to check. You do not need to grade every record yourself. A rough sort into clean, played and rough piles is a good start. Then find a shop that buys records.