Best Record Stores in Wisconsin
30 record stores in Wisconsin have been written up by the press. The top 15 are below, ranked by how many different publications covered each one. 18 have been covered by two or more.
How this is ranked. Each shop is placed by the number of independent publications that have written about it. A publication counts once per shop, by its website, however many pieces it ran, and a shop's own website never counts. Every article is linked so you can read it yourself. Ties go to the shop with more outside sources on file, then to the most recent write-up. There is no pay-to-play: shops can't buy a spot. A shop nobody has written about yet is not on this list, but it is still in the full directory.
- 1
Strictly Discs
5 publicationsMadison
Wisconsin's largest record shop, independently owned since 1988, with roughly 500,000 used LPs, 45s, CDs, tapes and hi-fi gear near the UW-Madison campus.
- 2
The Door
5 publicationsMadison
Tucked down an alley off Monona Drive, a metal- and punk-focused vinyl, CD and tape shop opened by longtime record-store veteran John Sands in June 2020.
- 3
B-Side Records
5 publicationsMadison
State Street institution since 1982; the last full-line record store on State Street, selling new and used vinyl after moving to a larger storefront in 2022.
- 4
MadCity Music Exchange
4 publicationsMadison
Madison's oldest continuously open record store, on Atwood Avenue since 2017; new and used vinyl, CDs, 45s and tapes, and a longtime hub for local musicians.
- 5
Rush-Mor Records
4 publicationsMilwaukee
Milwaukee's longest-running record shop, in Bay View since the early '90s under current owners. Deep punk, hardcore, metal, prog/Euro-rock, rockabilly and imports, plus new & used vinyl, CDs and DVDs.
- 6
Acme Records & Music Emporium
4 publicationsMilwaukee
Bay View staple opened by longtime collector and WMSE DJ Ken Chrisien, built out in reclaimed materials with a pipe-organ stage. Curated new & used vinyl and CDs, jazz through psych and post-punk.
- 7
Lilliput Records
4 publicationsMilwaukee
East Side shop that replaced the shuttered Exclusive Company at its longtime Farwell Ave location, launched by former Exclusive Company staff Tanner Musgrove and Brian Kirk via a community GoFundMe. New releases plus a growing used section and in-store DJ stage.
- 8
Irving Place Records
3 publicationsMilwaukee
East Side shop that took over the beloved Bullseye Records space, relaunched by veteran record-store staff Terry Hackbarth and Don Kurth on Record Store Day 2024. Doubled its floor space in 2025.
- 9
The Deep Groove
3 publicationsMilwaukee
A vinyl listening lounge and cafe on Brady Street in a former 1875 tavern building, pairing hundreds of spinnable records and a used-vinyl boutique with coffee by day and cocktails by night, plus live jazz and blues programming.
Written up by: - 10
JiggyJamz Vinyl & CDs
3 publicationsMadison
DJ-culture record shop specializing in house, techno, hip-hop and other electronic vinyl, run by longtime Madison DJ Geoff "Jiggy" Kaster, with a focus on local artists.
- 11
We Buy Records
2 publicationsMilwaukee
Riverwest shop run by musician Andy Noble (formerly of Lotus Land) with a fast-turning, buy-first inventory of 17,000+ LPs and 45s spanning funk, soul, jazz, rock and R&B.
Written up by: - 12
Record Head
2 publicationsWest Allis
West Allis record and media store operating since 1972, selling new and used vinyl, CDs, retro video games, musical instruments, and turntables/stereo gear.
Written up by: - 13
Grooves
2 publicationsRiver Falls
Full-service vinyl records and CDs shop in downtown River Falls, described by local press as the only business mainly devoted to selling records in town; also offers record cleaning.
Written up by: - 14
Back to the Vinyl
2 publicationsWaupaca
Independent record store selling vinyl, cassettes, CDs, posters and turntable accessories, with ultrasonic record-cleaning service; relocated to a larger downtown Waupaca space in Jan 2025.
Written up by: - 15
Omen Alternative Music and Media
2 publicationsSouth Milwaukee
Alternative media and fashion shop with a record section focused on punk, metal and industrial, plus dark wave, electronic and post-punk. Also sells clothing, jewelry, movies, posters and books.
Written up by:
Showing 15 of 30 press-covered shops. See all 54 record stores in Wisconsin · Know of a write-up we missed? Send the link