Not a suitcase player (whatever else you buy)
The one thing every shop agrees on, before any model gets mentioned
Four shops on two continents, asked separately, gave the same first answer: don't buy the cheap all-in-one with the speakers built in. Dusty Groove's co-founder says it from the returns counter: they sound bad, they break, and they track badly enough to wear your records. Flashback, Drift and 12 Bar say it to every beginner who walks in. Spend the same money on a real turntable and a pair of powered speakers and you'll still own it in ten years. Everything below starts from there.
Who uses it
- Dusty Groove Chicago, IL
“They not only sound terrible, [but] they [also] break down [and] they have a lot of problems with tracking. You're really not getting the full experience.”
Rick Wojcik, co-founder of Dusty Groove, quoted by NBC News Select. He's speaking from the store's own experience: 'When Dusty Grooves bought and sold record players and turntables, the store dealt wi
- NBC News Select 2021-12
- Flashback Records Crouch End London
“The best advice to people just getting into vinyl would be not to get a cheap all-in-one player. The sound won't be very good and you'll potentially ruin your records. Spend a little extra and get an entry-level turntable, separate amplifier and separate speakers.”
Flashback Records owner Mark Burgess, in the same What Hi-Fi? Record Store Day piece as the Drift Record Shop quote above. The article's own editor's note separately criticizes the Crosley Keepsake an
- What Hi-Fi? 2025-04
- Drift Record Shop Totnes
“Spend what money you have on a robust turntable. If the price seems too cheap, it's going to be a crappy experience. Use discovery platforms like blogs and streaming sites to find something you're into, and invest in vinyl when you love it.”
General buying philosophy from Drift Record Shop manager Rupert Morrison, given directly to What Hi-Fi? for Record Store Day 2025 coverage aimed at vinyl newbies. Not a named model, but it is real, da
- What Hi-Fi? 2025-04
- 12 Bar Music & Social Exeter
“My advice? Start with a good turntable and speakers (not one of those retro briefcase lookalikes – while they may look cool, the sound quality will be disappointing). Don't be afraid to ask for help when choosing records.”
12 Bar Music and Social founder Sam Tame, in the same What Hi-Fi? Record Store Day piece as the two entries above. An explicit warning against suitcase/all-in-one turntables from a third, unrelated sh
- What Hi-Fi? 2025-04