Best Record Stores in Ohio
48 record stores in Ohio have been written up by the press. The top 15 are below, ranked by how many different publications covered each one. 25 have been covered by two or more.
How this is ranked. Each shop is placed by the number of independent publications that have written about it. A publication counts once per shop, by its website, however many pieces it ran, and a shop's own website never counts. Every article is linked so you can read it yourself. Ties go to the shop with more outside sources on file, then to the most recent write-up. There is no pay-to-play: shops can't buy a spot. A shop nobody has written about yet is not on this list, but it is still in the full directory.
- 1
Spoonful Records
3 publicationsColumbus
Downtown vinyl staple opened in 2010 by husband-and-wife team Brett Ruland and Amy Kesting; ran weekly in-store Spoonful Sessions all through 2025.
- 2
Alien Records
3 publicationsCincinnati
New Over-the-Rhine vinyl destination opened Nov 2024 by Cincinnati native Timothy Henninger, seeded from his ~30,000-record personal collection. Also does turntable repair and live in-store events.
- 3
Feathers Vintage Clothing
3 publicationsDayton
Oregon District vintage-clothing and antiques shop since 1978 with a long-running vinyl records section spanning all genres and decades. One of downtown Dayton's oldest continually operating businesses.
- 4
Records Per Minute
3 publicationsColumbus
University District shop owned by Steve Louis with over 50,000 records in stock spanning pop, soul, rock, R&B, indie, and alternative, plus stereo gear.
- 5
Hollow Bone Records
2 publicationsFairlawn
Akron-area indie record store opened by Jerrod Woll in 2015 after he left a corporate sales career; new and used vinyl across rock, pop, blues, R&B, jazz, metal, punk, reggae, garage rock, hip hop, folk and country, plus in-store performances.
Written up by: - 6
Late Nite Records
2 publicationsCleveland
Late-hours record shop from owner Allen Wagner mixing rock, hip-hop and electronic vinyl, open into the night in Clark-Fulton/Tremont.
Written up by: - 7
Time Traveler Records
2 publicationsAkron
Akron tradition since 1980 and one of Northeast Ohio's longest-running independent record stores. Owner Scott Shepherd runs deep bins of used vinyl, CDs, and rare collector finds near downtown Akron.
Written up by: - 8
The Switchboard
2 publicationsToledo
Downtown bar sharing a building with Culture Clash Records. Vinyl bought next door gets spun on the house turntable, plus bring-your-own-vinyl nights and joint Record Store Day events with patio refreshments.
- 9
Catacomb Records
2 publicationsKettering
Metal-focused record shop in Kettering stocking death, black, doom, thrash, and industrial on vinyl, CD, and cassette, plus a listening room and record buying/trading.
- 10
Omega Music
2 publicationsDayton
Dayton's oldest and largest independent record store, anchoring the Oregon District since 1983. Deep new/used vinyl, CD, and cassette selection plus turntables and hi-fi gear; still family-owned by the Staigers.
- 11
Shake It Records
2 publicationsCincinnati
Nationally known Northside institution and former indie label; two floors of new/used vinyl, CDs, tapes, books and pop-culture ephemera. Run by brothers Jim and Darren Blasé.
Written up by: - 12
Mole's Record Exchange
2 publicationsCincinnati
Cincinnati's longest-running record store, in business since 1974 near UC in Clifton Heights. Deep crates of used vinyl and CDs plus posters and memorabilia; staffed by longtime regulars.
Written up by: - 13
Blue Arrow Records
2 publicationsCleveland
Award-winning used-vinyl anchor of the Waterloo Arts District, with its own in-house record label and a sales floor inlaid with vintage records.
Written up by: - 14
Culture Clash Records
2 publicationsToledo
Downtown Toledo's flagship record shop at Monroe & 10th, with a deep new-and-used vinyl selection spanning classic rock, jazz, hip-hop and punk, plus in-store live bands.
Written up by: - 15
Hausfrau Record Shop
2 publicationsCleveland
Ohio City record shop tucked upstairs from Visible Voice Books, curating punk, metal, jazz, world and experimental vinyl.
Written up by:
Showing 15 of 48 press-covered shops. See all 74 record stores in Ohio · Know of a write-up we missed? Send the link