Best record stores

Best Record Stores in New York

83 record stores in New York have been written up by the press. The top 15 are below, ranked by how many different publications covered each one. 35 have been covered by two or more.

How this is ranked. Each shop is placed by the number of independent publications that have written about it. A publication counts once per shop, by its website, however many pieces it ran, and a shop's own website never counts. Every article is linked so you can read it yourself. Ties go to the shop with more outside sources on file, then to the most recent write-up. There is no pay-to-play: shops can't buy a spot. A shop nobody has written about yet is not on this list, but it is still in the full directory.

  1. 1

    Academy Record Annex

    5 publications

    Brooklyn

    Brooklyn's largest independent record store, an offshoot of Manhattan's Academy Records, with deep used stacks of rock, punk, jazz, country and disco in Greenpoint.

  2. 2

    Hudson Valley Vinyl

    4 publications

    Beacon

    Downtown Beacon's "good old-fashioned, no-frills record shop," opened by longtime collector Chris Reisman in March 2017; vintage LPs across jazz, soul, r&b, rock, rap, reggae, blues, Latin, disco and psych. Relocating a few doors down to 323 Main St on Aug 1, 2026.

  3. 3

    Brooklyn Record Exchange

    4 publications

    Brooklyn

    Greenpoint new-and-used vinyl shop with a big, well-organized house/dance section; consolidated here after its Johnson Ave (Bushwick/East Williamsburg) location closed.

  4. 4

    Black Gold Records

    4 publications

    Brooklyn

    Carroll Gardens coffee shop and record store combo selling curated used vinyl alongside espresso drinks since 2010.

  5. 5

    Human Head Records

    4 publications

    Brooklyn

    Bushwick shop with over 5,000 new and used records, handpicked selection, and in-store listening stations for previewing before purchase.

  6. 6

    Darkside Records

    3 publications

    Poughkeepsie

    Hudson Valley's largest independent record shop and nine-time 'Best Record Store' winner; moved to a 19th-century downtown building in Nov 2025. Vinyl, CDs, cassettes, gallery space, and a bar.

  7. 7

    Second Hand Records NYC

    3 publications

    Brooklyn

    Bushwick/Bed-Stuy used-vinyl shop, Latino-owned and LGBTQ+ friendly, known for a wide, well-organized selection of soul, funk, R&B, and 12-inch singles.

  8. 8

    Vinyl Fantasy

    3 publications

    Brooklyn

    Bushwick storefront blending new and used vinyl (metal, punk and beyond) with comics, graphic novels and funky art; women-owned and Latino-owned.

  9. 9

    Sound House Records

    3 publications

    Troy

    Independent Troy record shop for new and used vinyl, cassettes, CDs, and vintage audio gear; opened June 2021 by Matthew Klein and George Weinisch.

  10. 10

    Record Archive

    3 publications

    Rochester

    Rochester's flagship record store since 1975: 13,000 sq ft with 250,000+ vinyl records, 60,000+ 45s and an in-house Backroom Lounge, with a full beer and wine bar, live music stage, listening parties, trivia and drag bingo.

  11. 11

    Brooklyn

    Williamsburg shop carrying mostly used vinyl across genres plus a rotating selection of new arrivals.

  12. 12

    Earwax Records

    3 publications

    Brooklyn

    Williamsburg vinyl shop selling records since 1991, one of the neighborhood's longest-running independent stores.

  13. 13

    Syracuse Vintage Vinyl

    3 publications

    East Syracuse

    Owner Tom Little's used-vinyl storefront in East Syracuse, built from nine years of selling records at the Regional Market, with 40,000+ LPs on hand.

  14. 14

    Kingston

    Uptown Kingston shop specializing in jazz, punk and everything else, new and used vinyl and CDs.

  15. 15

    River Street Beat Shop

    2 publications

    Troy

    Longtime downtown Troy buy/sell/trade shop for vinyl, CDs, and music memorabilia, run by owner Jim Barrett since 2004.

Showing 15 of 83 press-covered shops. See all 160 record stores in New York  ·  Know of a write-up we missed? Send the link