Best Record Stores in New Jersey
22 record stores in New Jersey have been written up by the press. The top 15 are below, ranked by how many different publications covered each one. 7 have been covered by two or more.
How this is ranked. Each shop is placed by the number of independent publications that have written about it. A publication counts once per shop, by its website, however many pieces it ran, and a shop's own website never counts. Every article is linked so you can read it yourself. Ties go to the shop with more outside sources on file, then to the most recent write-up. There is no pay-to-play: shops can't buy a spot. A shop nobody has written about yet is not on this list, but it is still in the full directory.
- 1
Princeton Record Exchange
3 publicationsPrinceton
One of the largest independent used-record stores in the United States, trading in Princeton since 1980 with roughly 140,000 titles across vinyl, CDs and DVDs.
- 2
The Vinyl Dinosaur
2 publicationsBayville
Full-service Ocean County music shop in Bayville selling vinyl, CDs, cassettes, DVDs, books, turntables and other audio gear.
Written up by: - 3
Sweet Vinyl Cafe
2 publicationsDenville
Record store, coffee bar and gift shop in downtown Denville selling new and used vinyl, CDs and music biographies, with treats and live events that feature original music only.
Written up by: - 4
Music Country
2 publicationsCliffside Park
Family-run since 1934 at its original Cliffside Park location, one of the oldest record stores in the US; vinyl LPs/45s/78s, CDs, cassettes, posters and collectibles.
Written up by: - 5
Tunes
2 publicationsHoboken
Hoboken buy/sell/trade shop for vinyl, CDs, DVDs and games, marking its 30th anniversary in December 2025.
Written up by: - 6
Inner Groove Records
2 publicationsCollingswood
Vinyl-only shop across the river from Philadelphia with stock that's roughly 90% used and vintage, spanning classic rock, jazz, funk, soul and reggae, plus an in-house reissue label.
Written up by: - 7
Rhythm Central Records
2 publicationsJersey City
Vintage record shop in the Jersey City Heights offering jazz, Latin, rock, soul, salsa, and disco vinyl, plus record-buying services.
Written up by: - 8
Station 1 Books & Vinyl
1 publicationPompton Lakes
Books, vinyl and vintage shop at the Pompton Lakes train station.
Written up by: - 9
Almost Ready Records (Montclair)
1 publicationMontclair
Montclair record shop, distinct from the Brooklyn shop of the same name; sells on Discogs and eBay in addition to its storefront.
Written up by: - 10
- 11
Vinyl Addiction Records
1 publicationNorth Arlington
Record shop in North Arlington, Bergen County.
Written up by: - 12
Record King
1 publicationSaddle Brook
Bergen County record shop, formerly a 56-year Hackensack fixture, now trading from Saddle Brook since a 2021 relocation.
Written up by: - 13
Valley Records & Antiques
1 publicationVernon
Vinyl and antique shop in Vernon, Sussex County, with a large variety of used vinyl plus posters, memorabilia and general antiques. Opened by Vernon native Tom Wilson Jr.
Written up by: - 14
Boro Records
1 publicationFreehold
Woman-owned boutique record shop in downtown Freehold selling new and used vinyl, CDs, tapes and gifts.
Written up by: - 15
14a Records
1 publicationBayonne
Bayonne record store opened in January 2025 by Robert Henry, selling new and vintage records, tapes, CDs and rare imports, and buying record collections of all sizes.
Written up by:
Showing 15 of 22 press-covered shops. See all 44 record stores in New Jersey · Know of a write-up we missed? Send the link