Best record stores

Best Record Stores in Indiana

24 record stores in Indiana have been written up by the press. The top 15 are below, ranked by how many different publications covered each one. 11 have been covered by two or more.

How this is ranked. Each shop is placed by the number of independent publications that have written about it. A publication counts once per shop, by its website, however many pieces it ran, and a shop's own website never counts. Every article is linked so you can read it yourself. Ties go to the shop with more outside sources on file, then to the most recent write-up. There is no pay-to-play: shops can't buy a spot. A shop nobody has written about yet is not on this list, but it is still in the full directory.

  1. 1

    Walkover Sounds & Stones

    3 publications

    Bloomington

    Downtown-square record shop buying, selling and trading new and used vinyl, CDs and music media; relocated street-level in Aug 2024 from its prior 26-year basement home as TD's CDs & LPs, run by owner Will Bewley.

  2. 2

    Welcome Back Records

    2 publications

    Fort Wayne

    Brick-and-mortar record store on South Calhoun St specializing in new and used vinyl, CDs, books, and audio equipment.

  3. 3

    Atmosphere Collectibles

    2 publications

    Evansville

    Indie record store on Stringtown Road buying, selling and trading vinyl, CDs and tapes.

  4. 4

    Black Wax Records

    2 publications

    Lafayette

    Downtown Lafayette record shop with a distinctive red-and-black storefront on Main St.

  5. 5

    Homefield at Tracks

    2 publications

    Bloomington

    Kirkwood Ave shop combining Tracks, Bloomington's vinyl record store since 1988, with Homefield Apparel's IU-licensed gear, under a partnership launched in fall 2025. Sells new and used vinyl across genres alongside collegiate apparel.

  6. 6

    JL Records

    2 publications

    West Lafayette

    The largest music store near Purdue, open since 1981, with a vast collection of vinyl, CDs and DVDs.

  7. 7

    Hobart

    Original Hobart location of Tom Lounges' Record Bin, before the owner opened a second store in Michigan City.

  8. 8

    Fort Wayne

    North Anthony Blvd branch of Wooden Nickel Records.

  9. 9

    Record Parlor of Muncie

    2 publications

    Muncie

    Downtown Muncie record shop in the historic Rose Court building, opened July 2025 after a decade-long vision to restore a record store to downtown.

  10. 10

    Space Monkey Records

    2 publications

    Evansville

    Evansville's vintage vinyl superstore, specializing in rock LPs with over 100,000 albums and 45s in stock.

  11. 11

    CTYZN Records

    2 publications

    Carmel

    Father-and-son-run record shop in the Carmel Arts & Design District selling vinyl, CDs, cassettes, and thrifted music finds; the first dedicated record store in Carmel, opened January 2026.

  12. 12

    Square Cat Vinyl

    1 publication

    Indianapolis

    Fountain Square record shop, performance venue, and bar in one. New and used vinyl (classics plus local/independent acts), CDs, coffee and beer; named one of the best record stores in the US by Vinyl Me Please.

  13. 13

    Von's Records & Posters

    1 publication

    West Lafayette

    Founded in 1968, Von's has served the Purdue/West Lafayette scene for decades from Chauncey Mall.

  14. 14

    Fort Wayne

    North Clinton St branch of Wooden Nickel Records, Fort Wayne's largest new-and-used vinyl retailer.

  15. 15

    The Local Vinyl

    1 publication

    Terre Haute

    Vinyl shop in the historic 12 Points district of Terre Haute, housed in a late-1800s building.

Showing 15 of 24 press-covered shops. See all 79 record stores in Indiana  ·  Know of a write-up we missed? Send the link